March 31, 2025
When it's time for a new roof, the options can feel overwhelming. As a homeowner, you want something that’s reliable, affordable, and built to last. Two of the most popular choices out there are asphalt shingles and metal roofing. I’ve had experience with both, and in this post, I’m going to walk you through everything you need to know before you make a decision. Whether you're planning a full roof installation or just exploring your options, understanding the pros and cons of each material is key.
We’ll compare asphalt shingles and metal roofing in terms of durability, cost, maintenance, energy efficiency, aesthetics, and climate suitability. I’ll also include real-world advice and things to consider that go beyond just product specs. By the end, you’ll be equipped to choose the best roofing material for your home and your needs.
Let’s start with a big one: durability. A roof is a major investment, and no one wants to replace it sooner than necessary.
Asphalt shingles are the most common roofing material in North America. They typically last 15 to 30 years, depending on the quality of the shingles, how well they’re installed, and your local weather conditions.
There are different grades of asphalt shingles: 3-tab (the most basic), architectural (also known as dimensional), and premium. The higher the grade, the longer it will last, but it’ll also cost more.
Pros:
Cons:
Metal roofing is much more durable. A metal roof can last 40 to 70 years or even longer. Some materials like copper or zinc have lifespans over 100 years.
Most residential metal roofs are made of aluminum or steel. They’re resistant to rot, insects, and fire. They also hold up well in storms.
Pros:
Cons:
Verdict:
If you’re looking for long-term value, metal roofing takes first prize on durability. But if you plan to sell your home in the next 10–15 years, asphalt shingles might make more financial sense.
Budget plays a big role in roof installation decisions. So how do these materials stack up when it comes to cost?
One of the main reasons asphalt shingles are so popular is their low upfront cost. They’re affordable to buy and install. On average, asphalt shingle roofs cost between $3.50 and $5.50 per square foot, including installation.
However, the trade-off for the lower price is the shorter lifespan and higher likelihood of needing repairs over time.
Metal roofs cost more initially—anywhere from $8 to $14 per square foot installed, depending on the material and style. That might feel like a big jump, but keep in mind the long-term savings.
Because metal roofs last two to three times longer and often require fewer repairs, the lifetime cost can be lower than asphalt. You may also get insurance discounts for having a metal roof, depending on where you live.
Verdict:
For short-term affordability, asphalt shingles are the clear winner. But if you’re thinking long-term and can handle the upfront expense, metal roofing may offer better value over time.
No one wants to spend their weekends dealing with roof issues. Let’s talk about maintenance.
Asphalt roofs need regular inspections, especially after storms. Shingles can crack, curl, or blow off, and moss or algae can grow in damp areas. Repairs are usually simple and low-cost, but they can add up over the years.
If your home is surrounded by trees, expect to clean out debris more often to avoid shingle damage and clogged gutters.
Metal roofs are much easier to maintain. They don’t rot or attract mold, and they’re tough against wind and pests. You’ll still want to check for dents, loose panels, or coating wear once or twice a year.
A properly installed metal roof with a good coating should require very little upkeep.
Verdict:
Metal roofing takes the lead here with less maintenance and fewer repairs. If low-maintenance living is a priority, it’s worth considering.
Heating and cooling your home is one of the biggest energy expenses you’ll have. Roofing plays a bigger role in this than many people realize.
Asphalt shingles absorb heat, especially in darker colors. In warm climates, this can make your attic hotter and cause your air conditioner to work harder. However, you can choose “cool roof” versions that reflect more sunlight, but these usually cost more.
Metal roofs are naturally reflective. Many have special coatings that reflect solar radiation and release heat, helping to keep your home cooler in summer. They also perform well in cold climates by shedding snow more efficiently, which helps prevent ice dams.
Some studies have shown that metal roofs can lower cooling costs by 10–25%, especially in warmer regions.
Verdict:
When it comes to energy efficiency, metal roofing wins hands down, especially in sunny or hot climates.
Looks matter, especially when it comes to curb appeal and resale value. So how do these materials compare visually?
Asphalt shingles come in a wide range of colors and styles. Architectural shingles can mimic the look of wood shake or slate. Most neighborhoods are filled with asphalt roofs, so they tend to blend in easily.
Pros:
Cons:
Metal roofing used to have a more industrial vibe, but not anymore. Today, you can choose from standing seam panels, metal tiles, and coatings that mimic traditional materials. Available in a range of colors, finishes, and styles, metal roofs can be a bold, modern design choice.
Pros:
Cons:
Verdict:
It comes down to personal taste. If you want classic and conventional, asphalt shingles are a safe bet. On the other hand, If you’re after a standout look with more style options, metal roofing suits your needs.
Different materials perform better in different weather conditions. Here’s what to know about climate compatibility.
Asphalt shingles work well in moderate climates. However, in areas with high heat, constant UV exposure can wear them down faster. They also struggle in areas with heavy snow, high winds, or frequent hail.
Metal is a top choice for extreme weather. It holds up against wind, snow, rain, and hail. It also resists fire and is great for wildfire-prone areas. Because metal sheds snow quickly, it's especially good in northern climates.
Verdict:
If you live in a region with extreme weather—hot summers, icy winters, or storm activity—metal roofing is the smarter choice. Asphalt may still work, but it’ll likely need more frequent attention.
Beyond features and specs, there are a few practical things to think about:
Some neighborhoods or homeowner associations have restrictions on roofing types or colors. Metal roofing may not be allowed in some areas, or it may require approval.
Rain hitting a metal roof can be louder than on asphalt shingles. With proper insulation and underlayment, it’s not usually a problem, but it’s something to think about.
Not all roofers specialize in metal roofing. Make sure your contractor is experienced with the material you choose. A bad install can shorten the life of any roof.
Metal roofing is surprisingly lightweight. This can be helpful for older homes or when installing over existing shingles. Asphalt is heavier by comparison.
A metal roof may increase your home’s resale value thanks to its durability and efficiency. But depending on the buyer, a traditional asphalt roof may be more expected.
There’s no one-size-fits-all answer here. Both asphalt shingles and metal roofing have their place, and the best roofing material for your home depends on your goals, budget, and location.
A roof is a big investment, and choosing the right material can save you money, time, and stress in the long run. If you're still unsure, talk to a local roofing contractor. They can assess your home, climate, and budget to recommend the best fit for your next roof installation.
Contact A&D Roofing LLC, your trusted roofing professional to get a personalized quote and expert advice on the best roofing materials for your home.
.webp)